Right, so I've been trying to figure out what to do and what is fair, and I think I'm going to extend voting until at least tomorrow night. Hopefully we can get it down to a single tie or end up with a clearly definitive winner. I'm going to advertise for some more votes, and I encourage you all to do the same.
Remember, do NOT specifically ask people to vote for your icons. Just let them know there is a close race and we could definitely use help deciding the winner.
I actually do have a single graphic I created months ago asking people to vote. If you'd like to use it you can find it here. The link directly to the voting page is as follows: http://torchwhostills.livejournal.com/31202.html
Thanks for all your help, and congrats to this week's icon makers who literally have us at a deadlock!